Posts / melbourne
What a Lake Is Called
There’s a lake near me that has had a name change, and it has taken over a surprising amount of roadside real estate. Berwick Springs Lake became Guru Nanak Lake in 2024. Since then, small signs reading “Berwick Springs” and “1855” have been showing up on fences and poles. A thread on r/Melbourne this week was a person saying they were sick of them. The comments suggest they aren’t alone.
I should say up front that I don’t know the full history, and I distrust anyone who says they do. Here is what I could piece together. The renaming was an election commitment in 2018. It went through two state elections before it happened. Some people say locals weren’t properly consulted. Others say the complaints only started once the sign was changed. Both can be partly true. A promise that sits in a platform for six years is not the same as a conversation with the people who walk their dogs there.
What struck me was how far the signs have travelled. People in the thread reported seeing them in Prahran, Port Melbourne, Frankston, Longwarry, out past Healesville, and as far as Bendigo and Ballarat. Someone saw one near Chadstone and said, fairly, that nobody in Chadstone cares what the lake is called. Someone had stuck a “nobody cares” sticker over one. I laughed at that.
A lake in Berwick is a local matter. A sign in Prahran about that lake is something else. Several commenters said the “1855” number is a dog whistle, tied to the year of Victoria’s Chinese immigration restriction laws, and that the whole thing has been picked up by white nationalist groups. I can’t verify that from my keyboard. I can say that the number has no obvious connection to the lake, and that people who say “we just want a say on a local name” don’t usually need to be in Bendigo to make the point. Maybe some of the sign-putters-up are sincere and some aren’t. Those two groups can share a fence post without sharing a motive.
It’s easy to turn this into a clean story where every objector is a bigot. I don’t think that’s accurate, and it’s not useful either. A fair few people in the outer suburbs feel that things get decided somewhere else and arrive with a plaque. That feeling is real, whatever it gets attached to. I live out here. I’ve watched a level crossing removal, a new estate and a shopping centre appear with about as much input from me as the weather gets. Some of the annoyance is about the name, and some of it is about being told after the fact.
Still, there’s a gap between “I would have liked to be asked” and a sticker campaign across half the state. One of those is a grievance. The other has become a hobby. The most sensible comment in the thread, I thought, was from someone who said that if changing a lake’s name is the biggest problem in your week, your week is going pretty well. Housing, hospitals and the 834 bus that doesn’t turn up are all on the list ahead of it.
The lake itself is lovely. It has the same ducks, the same slightly murky water and the same path with the same bad joggers. The ducks have no opinion on the matter. The original poster said the signs ruin the beauty of the place, and I think that’s true. Whatever you think the lake should be called, a lot of cheap corflute is a poor tribute to it.
I’d like to think this settles down. Names do. Plenty of places around here have been renamed and nobody remembers the fuss. I’ll probably still call it Berwick Springs by accident for years, out of habit. That seems fine. It’s a free country, as someone in the thread pointed out, and nobody gets fined for deadnaming a lake.