Posts / ai

Useful, Overhyped, and Not Mine to Fix


The top of r/technology today reads like a weather warning. Nvidia down 12% and on its longest weekly losing streak since 2008. US tech stocks in a bear market. An AI company’s IPO stumbling on day one. Somewhere in the middle, a headline about a game selling $3.79 billion in a day, which tells you something about the world, though I’m not sure what.

I read the comments on a couple of these over breakfast. They’re angry, mostly. A fair bit of swearing, a lot of “number must go up” and “pump and dump”. I understand the mood. I’ve also been in enough planning meetings to know that anger is the easy part.

The comment that stuck with me was from someone who said they were a CTO at a fast-growing company. They’d been trying to build a responsible AI adoption plan. The CEO and the tech team kept overruling them. The mandate was “adopt AI or else”, so they were conceding and letting the cards fall. It was one paragraph, with no villain in it, and it was the most believable thing on the page.

That matches what I see. Nobody I work with is a cartoon billionaire. The pressure comes from above, then from the board, then from a competitor’s press release. Someone buys a pile of licences, and then a summit is held so the staff who are “definitely not being replaced” can explain how to use them. Another commenter described exactly that. I laughed, then went quiet, because I’ve sat in that summit.

The other thread I liked was the argument over whether the technology is a flop. The replies sorted themselves out quickly, and most landed on the same answer. It’s useful, it’s overvalued, and those two things don’t contradict each other. One person pointed at the Gartner hype cycle and the trough of disillusionment. It’s a bit of a cliché by now, but clichés are often just correct.

I’ll admit where I sit. I use these tools every week. They’re good at the dull parts of my job: boilerplate, a first pass at a script, working out what an ancient config file was trying to do. A few years ago that would have felt like magic. I’m still fascinated by it. But “good at boilerplate” is a long way from “worth four trillion dollars”, and a market can be wrong about that for a long time before it stops being wrong.

I also don’t know how this plays out. Some confident people in the comments think we’re a year or two from something that changes everything. Other confident people think it’s all a grift. I’ve been wrong about technology in both directions, so I’m holding both loosely. If it does hit a turning point, I’d like the people in charge to have thought about what comes next for the rest of us. So far the evidence for that is thin.

What bothers me more than the share prices is who pays when the correction arrives. A few comments mentioned the RAM and SSD prices, and a small IT business that nearly went under chasing hardware at spot pricing. My daughter wants a new laptop this year, and I’ve been watching memory prices like a man watching a pot he’s been told will boil over. I like a bargain, and there aren’t many going around at the moment. That’s a petty complaint next to the bigger ones, but it’s where I feel the bubble: in the price of ordinary things. The upside went to a few shareholders, and the cost lands on schools, small businesses and teenagers who need a laptop for homework.

This is where I come back to the tension. I want public institutions to have a say in how this goes, and I don’t want the answer to be “ban it”. Rules written by people who understand the tech are better than panic or worship, and there’s less of both than the comment section suggests. Plenty of those commenters are right about the incentives and wrong about the remedy, which is usually how it goes online. I’m probably the same.

Back to work, where I have a meeting about AI. I’ll ask what problem we’re actually trying to solve. It’s a small question, and it’s the only one I’ve ever seen move a room.