Posts / cost-of-living
The Ten Dollar Block of Cheese
Someone on r/AussieFrugal has posted a price comparison of 1kg blocks of tasty cheese across Woolworths, Coles and Aldi. It’s a modest piece of public service. Aldi wins at $8.79. Coles Simply Cheddar and the Hillview block are $9.30. Everything else sits at $10.50. The comments are mostly people arguing about whether Aldi’s cheese is brilliant or rubber.
The comment that stuck with me was the first one. Someone said they blinked and cheese went from $5 to $10. I’ve had the same feeling. I can’t point to the day it happened. It’s a block of cheese, I buy one most weeks, and at some point it crossed a line I hadn’t noticed. Maybe it was the psychological barrier of two digits. More likely I wasn’t paying attention, which is how most price rises work.
A few things in the thread interested me.
First, the Hillview business. The block is now made in the USA, and the verdict from several people is that it’s flavourless. One user grated some, put it in a container, and found it had gone wet and soggy. I have no way of checking that. But three or four people independently calling the same product bland is the sort of evidence I’ll accept. Another user said they’d avoid US dairy and beef regardless of price, even if the current regime there is toppled. I understand the impulse. I also notice that my own boycott resolve tends to last until the shelf tag is bigger than my principles. Both things are true for me, and I don’t have a tidy answer.
Second, the Aldi lottery. People love Aldi cheese, and people get mould on it in a week. One user said it’s sharp and crumbly one month and more like Colby the next, and they hope it never changes. That’s the most affectionate description of inconsistent quality I’ve ever read. I’m in the Aldi camp, mostly. The vintage is the one I’d defend. My household’s trick is cutting the block in half and freezing one piece, which a commenter also recommended. It goes a bit crumbly after thawing, but it’s perfect for toasties and pasta bakes. I’m mildly proud of this and will bring it up at dinner parties.
Third, and the one I keep turning over, someone told everyone not to be tight about cheese. The argument is that it takes about ten litres of milk to make a kilo, and buying the cheapest block squeezes the dairy farmer. Then buy local, otherwise we’ll be eating cheese from China.
There’s something in it. Dairy farmers have been squeezed for decades. Anyone who remembers the 2016 milk price cuts by Murray Goulburn and Fonterra knows how brutal that was for farms in Gippsland, which isn’t far from where I live. I care about that.
But the reply to that comment was better than the comment. A person said they’d been supporting a family of four on one income for nine years, seven of them paycheque to paycheque, and they’d keep buying the cheap cheese. That’s the whole argument. You can’t ask a household at the edge to carry the ethics of a supply chain. If the farmer is being squeezed, a lot of the squeezing happens upstream of the shopper, in a supermarket duopoly with enormous bargaining power over suppliers. Aldi cheese is also Australian, by the way. The label says so. The poster listed the origin for each one, which is a handy bit of the research that most of us skip.
So I don’t know where the fault sits. I suspect the honest answer is that a block of cheese is a small proxy for a bigger argument about who gets paid at each step. The ACCC has looked at supermarket pricing and found a lot of market power concentrated in two companies. A shopper picking the $8.79 block is not the villain in that story.
What I did take away is simple. Someone spent time writing out nine prices so strangers could save a dollar or two. That’s the best of these forums. Cheese is up, wages aren’t keeping pace, and a bloke or woman with a spreadsheet and a free evening is doing more for the household budget than most of the commentary on the subject. I’ll buy the Aldi block this week, cut it in half, and freeze one piece.