Posts / cleaning

The Smell of Someone Else's Life


Someone on r/CleaningTips has bought a house from an elderly woman and can’t shift what they call the “old lady smell”. They’ve tried wax melts, washed the floors and walls, and left the windows open. Every visitor still mentions it. The post has well over a hundred comments, which tells you it’s a common problem.

The consensus is paint the walls, get the ducts cleaned, and stop using the wax melts. That all sounds right to me. Wax melts on top of a smell don’t remove it. You just get a smell with a second smell on top.

The comment I liked most was from someone who asked what “old lady smell” actually means. Is it mustiness, mothballs, or sixty years of rose talc and potpourri? Is it cooking? Is it damp? Each of those has a different fix. This is the same instinct that makes a decent sysadmin ask “what does ‘it’s slow’ mean?” before touching anything. I spend a lot of my working life on vague bug reports. “Smells old” is a vague bug report.

Another person bought a house from a 94 year old and did everything on the list. Carpet out, drapes out, vents vacuumed, walls painted. The smell stayed. Then the furnace technician pointed at the condensation pump reservoir, which had gone cloudy. A capful of bleach every six weeks fixed it. I find that satisfying. The cause was one small neglected thing, hiding behind a lot of big and obvious effort.

Then there was the long reply from someone who had cleaned a 75 year old house top to bottom. They found the smell was strongest in rooms with west and south windows. The sun had baked it into the curtains and it “bloomed” in the light. They lived with brown builder’s paper over the windows for six months. They sealed the inside of a vanity cabinet with polyurethane. They replaced the toilet, as they do in every house they move into. I admire that level of commitment. I’m not sure I’d have the patience, but I admire it.

One more comment stuck with me. A person with no sense of smell said their friends keep telling them the house smells like an old folks home, and even the dog does now. They can’t find the source because they can’t smell it. Someone suggested asking the friends to be more specific. It’s good advice, and it’s also a slightly sad thing to have to do.

We bought our place second-hand too. It’s a 1990s brick veneer in the outer southeast, and the previous owners were a lovely couple who had a dog and, I think, a lot of fried onions. For the first month I thought the place was fine. Then we went away for a week, came back, and the smell hit me at the front door. You stop noticing your own house, and a holiday resets your nose. That’s the only reliable test I know. I don’t know a fix for the nose problem, but I do know that the carpet was the main culprit. We replaced it, and the smell went with it. The rest was elbow grease and a lot of vinegar that I’m not sure did anything.

What I like about the thread is that there’s no real tension in it, just a lot of strangers being practical on behalf of someone they’ll never meet. Someone is stuck in a house that smells wrong, and a hundred people turn up with a theory about the drainage, the ducts and the sunlight. The theories are mostly good.

Underneath it all, it’s a bit tender. A house holds a person’s habits for decades, and the new owner is scrubbing out someone else’s life. The smell is a kind of record. I hope the original poster gets rid of it, and I also hope they take a moment, before the paint goes on, to think about the woman who lived there. She seems to have been sweet, and the house was home to her for a long time.

Check the condensation pump first, though.