Posts / ai
The Apprenticeship Problem
A junior lawyer posted on r/auscorp this week, and it has stuck with me. The firm has rolled out an AI tool built for legal work. The seniors are delighted. One of them said, roughly, that he could now do in five minutes what used to mean handing it to someone and waiting for the review. Clients are running the firm’s drafts through their own AI, and some of them just stop replying after a couple of rounds. The poster’s guess is that the machine is now doing the job they hired the firm for.
The poster is thinking about going in-house, or becoming a cop. They signed off with a sad face.
I work in IT, so I’ve had a few years’ head start on this feeling. Every few months a tool arrives that does something I used to bill as skill. I’m fascinated by it. I’m also a bit queasy about it. Both are true at once, and I’ve stopped trying to settle the argument.
The comments were what you’d expect. Someone said every white collar job is in the same boat. Someone said it’ll be better than a five-year engineer by the end of the year. Someone suggested the government should just ban AI, because it worked so well for social media and under-16s. That one got the reply it deserved: it’s offshore, and half the kids are still on it anyway.
I don’t know how fast this goes. One commenter made a fair point that a lot of the recent job cuts get blamed on AI when they look more like ordinary offshoring and margin-chasing with a shinier excuse. I think that’s partly right. I also think the cost of running these models is real, and that the tools may not be cheap enough yet to replace everyone. But I wouldn’t bet my daughter’s career on “not yet”.
What I keep coming back to isn’t whether the senior lawyer is fine. He probably is. It’s where the next senior lawyer comes from.
Junior work was always partly a tax. You drafted the dull thing, a senior tore it apart, and you learned what good looks like. Nobody designed it as a training program, but it was one. In my own field, I learned most of what I know from fixing other people’s broken deployments at 11pm. It was miserable and it was the best education I had. If the grunt work goes to a model, the senior gets faster today and the pipeline quietly dries up. The bill arrives in fifteen years, when there’s a shortage of people who can tell whether the output is wrong.
The best comment I read was from a lawyer who has embraced the tools. His advice was to lean in, but not to accept the output without understanding it. He said he learned by reading old precedents and other people’s work, and that none of that has to stop. He even suggested he might have learned faster with the tools. I think he’s right. I also think it takes a particular kind of discipline to read the precedent when a machine will hand you the answer. At 22, tired, with a billing target, I’m not sure I would have.
That’s the part that needs a human decision, not a technical one. Firms could choose to keep juniors doing real work and treat it as an investment. Most won’t, because the quarter is shorter than the career. This is where I’d normally say something about policy, and I will: universities, professional bodies and governments should be thinking hard about training now, not after the graduate intake collapses. Australia is good at noticing a problem the year after it’s become a crisis. I’d like us to try something different.
To the junior lawyer: I can’t tell you it’ll be fine. I don’t know. I can tell you that the people who understand both the work and the tool are the ones I’d want to keep, and that being scared of something you’re paying close attention to is not a character flaw. It’s roughly the correct response.
Becoming a cop seems a bit extreme. Although I’m told the pay is decent.