Posts / melbourne
Everything Leads to Flinders Street
Someone on r/Melbourne posted a map this week of where the jobs on Seek were. It was a short video of dots appearing across the city. There’s a big bright knot in the CBD and a lot of scattered dots out in the suburbs. The poster built it because two jobs both listed as “Melbourne” can mean wildly different commutes, and he wanted to see the difference.
I’ve been thinking about it since. Not because the map surprised me, but because of what one commenter said under it. Only about 9 per cent of jobs are in the CBD. About 22 per cent are in the City of Melbourne council area. Yet every train line in the network points at the city. Their words, roughly: it’s a pure hub-and-spoke system, and it’s very good if you want to go to Flinders Street and not much use otherwise.
I can’t verify those numbers. They match what I see from where I sit, though.
I live out in the southeast. For me the train is a good way to get to the city and a poor way to get anywhere else. If I need to get to Dandenong or Monash, I’m in the car. A cross-town trip that should take twenty minutes can turn into a mini expedition. Another commenter gave a good example: Upfield to Broadmeadows is about 3 kilometres. By train it’s over an hour and a quarter, going into the city and back out again. You could walk it faster. You could ride a bike in fifteen minutes. That’s less a transport network than a very long way of proving a point.
The usual defence is that the network was built when everyone worked in the city. Someone made that argument, and it sounds right. Someone else replied that the suburbs have always had most of the jobs, and that in the 1950s only about a quarter of jobs were in the CBD. I like that kind of reply. It’s one number that quietly knocks over a story everyone assumed was true. I don’t know which of them has the better data, but I’d bet on the one who brought a figure.
Working from home gets blamed for a lot, and I do it most days. But it’s apparently only about 15 per cent of working days across the whole workforce. That’s a bump, not a revolution. The job map was already lopsided toward the suburbs before any of us bought a standing desk.
So the Suburban Rail Loop keeps coming up, and it’s hard to avoid. It’s the one project that tries to fix the hub-and-spoke problem directly, by linking the lines to each other so you don’t have to go through the middle. There was a separate thread the same day asking what the Liberals’ actual policy on it is. Pause, delay, cancel, continue: it seems every MP has a different answer, and the shadow minister was claiming a pause would save tens of billions. I don’t know what the right number is. I’m sceptical of the cost, and I’m sceptical of anyone who is very confident about it in either direction.
I’ll hold two views here. The SRL is enormously expensive, and I’d want to see the business case argued properly, not just waved around at a press conference. I also think a network that makes you travel into the city to get from one suburb to the next is a design problem that doesn’t go away if we ignore it. Cancelling the one thing aimed at it, and then putting the money into another road, feels like treating the symptom. Then again, I’ve said that about roads before and watched them fill up anyway.
What gets me is how political it’s become. One commenter reckoned that if it’s killed, no politician will touch a project like this for forty years. That might be too gloomy. But big infrastructure gets hard to do once it becomes a football, and Melbourne has a long record of building things at about half the speed it needs to.
I did find one small thing to like in the thread. Someone pointed out that Port Melbourne has a lot of tech jobs and a lot of parking, and almost nothing to eat nearby. That one made me laugh, because it’s every business park I’ve ever worked in. We plan where people work and where they get lunch as if they’re separate problems.
I don’t have a tidy ending. The map is just dots. But it’s a decent reminder that the city we live in isn’t the one our rail lines were drawn for, and that fixing it will cost money and take longer than anyone wants. I’d still rather we tried.